At the heart of the Trades Awards is something we take incredibly seriously -
fairness, transparency, and recognising the very best in our industry.
Each year, we bring together a panel of experienced professionals from across
the North of Scotlandâs construction sector and beyond. Their role is simple in
principle, but challenging in reality: to review every application carefully,
fairly, and independently, and to identify the individuals and businesses truly
deserving of recognition.
With entries coming from businesses of all sizes, from sole traders to large
organisations, itâs essential that our judging process is robust, balanced, and
credible, and thatâs exactly what our panel delivers.
Our 2026 Judging Panel
Weâre proud to introduce this yearâs panel of judges, who bring a wide range
of expertise from across the industry:
- Kim Woolner â Head Judge
- Andrew Low â AtkinsRĂ©alis
- Darren Ross â STV
- Darren Cocker â CHAP
- Elaine Donald â W M Donald
- Fiona Inkster â Search
- Gail Smith â Scotia Roofing Supplies
- Jim Booth â Tullos Training
- Joe Boyle â Joe Boyle Consulting
- Kevin Urquhart â Barratt Homes and David Wiilson Homes
- Michelle Forth-Burnett â Safety Scotland
- Neil Thomson â Consultant
- Sarah Stuart â Thorntons Law
- Scott Kelly â SJPP
- Stephen Hepburn â NFU Mutual
- Suzanne Cameron - urbanbubble
Each judge brings their own perspective, knowledge, and experience, ensuring
that every category is assessed with the right level of understanding and
insight.
How the Judging Process Works
We know that entering awards can feel like a big step, so itâs important that
everyone understands how the process works behind the scenes.
Independent Review
Once applications close, entries are shared with the judging panel. Each judge
reviews submissions independently, scoring them based on clear criteria
specific to each category. This ensures every application is assessed on its own
merit.
Panel Discussion
Judges then come together in smaller groups to discuss their scores and
insights. These discussions help to ensure consistency across categories and
allow different perspectives to be considered.
From this stage, finalists are selected in each category, depending on the
quality and number of entries.
Finalist Interviews
All finalists are invited to take part in in-person interviews, held at Mearns &
Gill. This is a key part of the process. It gives finalists the chance to:
- Bring their application to life
- Share more detail about their work
- Answer questions directly from the judges
It also allows judges to gain a deeper understanding of each business, project
or individual beyond the written submission.
Final Decisions
Following the interviews, judges reconvene to make their final decisions.
Every decision is based on:
- Evidence provided in the application
- Evidence gathered during the interview
- Alignment with the category criteria
The goal is always to ensure that the most deserving winners are recognised.
Read More